By Paul Spillman
Is Southeastern Conference Commissioner Greg Sankey deliberately setting up LSU to make an example of? Does LSU continue to provide Sankey cause? It sure seems that way for both.
The conference’s ongoing dispute with LSU became much uglier this week thanks to mixed signals from both the conference and LSU. But at least this time is was LSU president Wade Rousse and not the Attorney General or the governor responding to the conference.
What’s going on now? It’s the continuing saga of former professional basketball player R.J. Luis becoming eligible to play for LSU, and not just eligible to play but actually taking the court for the Tigers – which he did for LSU’s win over Louisiana Monroe Wednesday night, proving this writer should stay out of the prediction game.
Here’s the recap: When Will Wade was hired for his second stint at LSU every current player had or eventually did enter the transfer portal. Wade had no basketball players on his basketball team. Early signing day for high school had already occurred and only a few recruits remained to be signed in April. Wade didn’t land any of those but did grab four guys out of the portal when it opened in early April. But LSU was not then an attractive destination forcing Wade to take a different route. He leaned heavily on taking advantage of the eligibility of class of 2022 players granted a fifth year, and international club pros who for decades have skirted the issue of professionalism to gain eligibility at American colleges and universities.
One of the first of those questionable players was R.J. Luis. Luis played at St. John’s and was the Big East player of the year and a second team All-American in 2025. But what separates Luis from every other eligibility issue at LSU is the fact he voluntarily gave up his remaining college eligibility to enter the NBA draft. He went undrafted but signed a two-way contract with Utah – which clearly results in loss of eligibility according to NCAA rules – was traded to and signed with Boston, played in a couple of preseason games, and eventually cut.
But the NCAA no longer has absolute rule-enforcing authority so Luis did what thousands of other athletes have done in recent years and sued the NCAA to regain his eligibility. He won a preliminary injunction in August, the day before the SEC presidents panicked and overreacted with an over-broad rule denying eligibility to anyone who signed with various professional teams it listed and vowing extreme punishment to rule-breakers. Readers might remember a similar controversy with LSU football coach Lane Kiffin and a couple of former Ole Miss players. Both examples were the initial impetus for the SEC’s alarm with LSU. That and the fact it was the governor and his attack AG speaking for LSU and not the school president or athletic director, Verge Ausberry. Ausberry might be well liked but he could just as well not even exist for all his involvement since being hired.
The SEC then used the excuse of “lack of institutional control” to threaten LSU, eventually with being expelled from the conference. Then the conference took the unusual step of filing a lawsuit against LSU, the board of supervisors, the governor, the AG, and various others in federal court seeking to prevent those named from stopping a vote to expel LSU from the conference. But after a few weeks it seemed to cool off a bit. Kiffin submitted his final roster and Wade said repeatedly he would abide by SEC rules concerning his roster. He did not add Luis to the roster when the season began. LSU submitted a motion to dismiss the case but the lawsuit is ongoing.
Meanwhile Judge William Jorden in the 19th Judicial Court in Baton Rouge late last week granted Luis an injunction affirming his eligibility at LSU and enjoining the conference from punishing either LSU or Wade. Baton Rouge attorney Tony Clayton, representing Luis, threatened a lawsuit against LSU if the school didn’t add Luis to its men’s basketball roster. But LSU didn’t add Luis to its roster, traveling to Spokane, Washington for a game with perennial power Gonzaga without Luis.
Then on Monday afternoon the SEC contacted Luis’ attorneys with this:
“The SEC will abide by the terms of the preliminary injunction while it remains in place and will not impose penalties or fines on LSU if it places Mr. Luis on its men’s basketball roster.”
Tuesday morning – after the SEC responded to the ruling on Monday – Wade announced Luis would be added to the roster. Later Tuesday afternoon Rousse released the following statement:
“LSU signed RJ in May 2026. He is a full-time LSU student. He went to court when he believed the NCAA had violated his rights. After a full evidentiary hearing, the Court ruled in his favor and enjoined the NCAA from declaring or treating him as ineligible. Neither the appellate court nor the Louisiana Supreme Court has disturbed that ruling. Under the SEC rules at the time, that ruling made him eligible to compete in the SEC as well. The day after that ruling was issued, the SEC announced its more aggressive interpretation of the eligibility rules with program-ending penalties for violations. RJ secured his eligibility through a court order before the new SEC policy interpretation was announced. LSU supports that updated policy going forward, and we remain a proud and committed member of the SEC.”
Tuesday evening the Southeastern Conference office released this statement:
“LSU’s decision today to rely on its own interpretation of the Court’s order to justify its actions is inconsistent with the expectations and responsibilities of membership in the Southeastern Conference. This is a deeply concerning and disappointing development. The Conference will continue to uphold and defend the standard and its policies established by its member universities.”
Does that sound like a not-so-veiled threat? Because it kind of sounds like a not-so-veiled threat. Especially following the response to Luis’ attorneys. But then, LSU was not forced to add Luis to its roster. It chose to. And that’s disappointing for multiple reasons. While the ethics and the legalities of it or the escalation with the conference can be debated the simple matter is LSU doesn’t need Luis. Wade did end up signing a high school recruit or two and all those fifth year returnees and international club pros are ruled eligible by the NCAA. Wade took a team of international players, fifth year oldsters, some transfers, and a few fresh-faced recruits to Spokane and defeated Gonzaga on a court where the ‘Zags had amassed a 190-9 record against non-conference opponents since 2012. Now 190-10. LSU has a team capable of winning at the highest level without R.J. Luis.
LSU is not the only school in America or in the Southeastern conference to roster players who have had eligibility issues, nor are all of them settled yet. According to College Sports Litigation Tracker at least 76 eligibility issue lawsuits are in active litigation. LSU is just the school Greg Sankey has chosen to fight with.
Nor is it just Sankey. Georgia Attorney General Christopher Carr wrote a second letter to Sankey demanding sanctions on LSU “up to and including expulsion.” It should be noted the conference and Alabama went through a very similar issue with Charles Bediako last season without either Sankey or Carr setting their hair on fire over it.
Congress won’t be any “help” either as it is consumed with the results of the midterms. Then, Congress was never going to be any real help though it might have ended most legal challenges. But for now college athletics is still a wild, wild west and the Southeastern Conference and LSU are headed for a showdown.



